Privacy Ratings

Best email services

The best email service depends on what you need, but privacy and security are easy to compare when every answer links to evidence. This ranking covers every email provider we rate, including mainstream services, scored on the same public criteria.

  1. 1. Forward Email Grade A Our pick

    Open-source email service with encrypted mailboxes, custom domains, and IMAP, POP3, SMTP, CalDAV and CardDAV on every paid plan.

    Why it is our pick: The whole service is published on GitHub, server code included. Each mailbox is a separately encrypted SQLite file, IMAP, POP3, SMTP, CalDAV and CardDAV work with any app, and custom domains are included on low-cost plans.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 98/100.

  2. 2. mailbox.org Grade C

    Paid email, calendar and office service from Berlin, Germany, with built-in PGP encryption and support for custom domains.

    Based in Germany (Fourteen Eyes). Score 70/100.

  3. 3. StartMail Grade C

    Paid email service from the Netherlands with built-in PGP encryption, unlimited aliases and custom domains.

    Based in the Netherlands (Nine Eyes). Score 68/100.

  4. 4. CounterMail Grade C

    Paid email service in Sweden that encrypts mail with OpenPGP and stores it encrypted. New registrations are closed.

    Based in Sweden (Fourteen Eyes). Score 63/100.

  5. 5. Aster Mail Grade C

    Email service from Aster Communications Inc. in the United States, with servers in Germany. Mail between Aster users is end-to-end encrypted with a hybrid post-quantum key exchange. Free and paid plans, no ads in the service.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 62/100.

  6. 6. Tuta Grade C

    End-to-end encrypted email and calendar service from Germany, with open-source apps for web, desktop and mobile.

    Based in Germany (Fourteen Eyes). Score 62/100.

  7. 7. Kolab Now Grade C

    Paid email and groupware service from Apheleia IT in Switzerland, built on the open-source Kolab platform, with calendars, contacts, files and video calls.

    Based in Switzerland. Score 61/100.

  8. 8. Posteo Grade C

    Paid, ad-free email service from Germany that runs without collecting names or addresses and accepts anonymous payment.

    Based in Germany (Fourteen Eyes). Score 60/100.

  9. 9. Proton Mail Grade C

    End-to-end encrypted email service from Switzerland, with apps for web, Android, iOS and desktop.

    Based in Switzerland. Score 60/100.

  10. 10. Disroot Grade D

    Volunteer-run platform from the Netherlands offering email and other open services.

    Based in the Netherlands (Nine Eyes). Score 59/100.

  11. 11. Soverin Grade D

    Paid email service from Soverin B.V. in Amsterdam, the Netherlands, with custom domains, unlimited aliases and calendar and contact sync. There is no free plan and no advertising.

    Based in the Netherlands (Nine Eyes). Score 56/100.

  12. 12. Riseup Grade D

    Email, mailing list and VPN service run by an autonomous tech collective in Seattle for activists and social movements. Accounts need an invite, and the service is funded by donations.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 55/100.

  13. 13. Infomaniak Mail Grade D

    Email service from Swiss company Infomaniak, with free ik.me addresses and paid hosting for custom domains, plus web and mobile apps.

    Based in Switzerland. Score 54/100.

  14. 14. Purelymail Grade D

    Low-cost email hosting from the United States with custom domains, standard protocols and mail stored encrypted with the user's password.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 51/100.

  15. 15. Mailfence Grade D

    Email service from Belgium with built-in OpenPGP encryption and signing, plus calendar, contacts and document storage.

    Based in Belgium (Fourteen Eyes). Score 50/100.

  16. 16. Runbox Grade D

    Paid email service from Norway with custom domain hosting, standard protocols and an open-source webmail app.

    Based in Norway (Nine Eyes). Score 50/100.

  17. 17. Amazon WorkMail Grade D

    Paid business email and calendar service on AWS for custom domains, billed per user. AWS has announced the end of support for WorkMail and no longer accepts new customers.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 48/100.

  18. 18. Fastmail Grade D

    Paid email service from Australia with custom domains and standard protocols.

    Based in Australia (Five Eyes). Score 48/100.

  19. 19. Secria Grade D

    Email service from Secria, Inc. in the United States, with mail stored in Germany. Mail between Secria users is end-to-end encrypted with a hybrid post-quantum key exchange. Free and paid plans, with no ads.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 46/100.

  20. 20. iCloud Mail Grade D

    Email service included with every Apple Account, with @icloud.com addresses and custom domains for iCloud+ subscribers.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 44/100.

  21. 21. Zoho Mail Grade D

    Email service from Zoho for businesses and individuals, with custom domains, calendar and contacts, and an ad-free free plan.

    Based in India. Score 41/100.

  22. 22. Gmail Grade D

    Google's free email service. Mail is stored and processed on Google's servers, and Google Workspace offers it for business domains.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 40/100.

  23. 23. Thundermail Grade D

    Paid email, calendar and contacts service from MZLA Technologies, the Mozilla subsidiary that makes Thunderbird. Built on the Stalwart mail server, with data hosted in Germany. In beta and open only by invitation from a waitlist.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 40/100.

  24. 24. GoDaddy Email Grade F

    Business email for custom domains sold by GoDaddy. It runs on Microsoft 365 (Exchange Online), with Outlook webmail and apps.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 39/100.

  25. 25. Migadu Grade F

    Swiss email hosting service for custom domains, priced by usage rather than per mailbox, with standard IMAP, POP3 and SMTP access.

    Based in Switzerland. Score 39/100.

  26. 26. Namecheap Private Email Grade F

    Paid email hosting from Namecheap for custom domains, with webmail, calendar and standard protocol access.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 38/100.

  27. 27. GandiMail Grade F

    Paid email hosting for custom domains from Gandi, a French domain registrar, with SOGo and Roundcube webmail and standard protocol access.

    Based in France (Nine Eyes). Score 35/100.

  28. 28. WEB.DE Grade F

    Free, ad-supported email service from 1&1 Mail & Media in Germany, with webmail, mobile apps, calendar and cloud storage. Paid plans remove third-party ads and ad tracking.

    Based in Germany (Fourteen Eyes). Score 35/100.

  29. 29. Mailo Grade F

    Email service from France, formerly Net-C and NetCourrier, with calendar, contacts and cloud storage. Mailo Free shows advertising banners. Paid Premium plans have no ads and add POP3 access.

    Based in France (Nine Eyes). Score 34/100.

  30. 30. Outlook.com Grade F

    Microsoft's free email service, also used for Hotmail and Live addresses.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 34/100.

  31. 31. HEY Grade F

    Paid email service from 37signals with a screening-based inbox and its own apps. Works only through the HEY apps, without IMAP or POP3.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 30/100.

  32. 32. GMX Grade F

    Free, ad-supported email service from 1&1 Mail & Media in Germany, with webmail, mobile apps, calendar and cloud storage.

    Based in Germany (Fourteen Eyes). Score 29/100.

  33. 33. Hushmail Grade F

    Paid email service with OpenPGP encryption from Hush Communications in Vancouver, Canada, where its servers are. Most plans are for healthcare, law and small business, and a Personal Use plan is sold to individuals.

    Based in Canada (Five Eyes). Score 29/100.

  34. 34. Titan Grade F

    Business email service for custom domains, sold through hosting and domain providers rather than directly. Includes webmail, mobile apps and a free plan with fewer features.

    Based in the Cayman Islands. Score 29/100.

  35. 35. Yahoo Mail Grade F

    Free, ad-supported email service from Yahoo with webmail and mobile apps. A paid Yahoo Mail Plus plan removes ads.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 28/100.

  36. 36. Yandex Mail Grade F

    Free, ad-supported email service from Yandex in Russia, part of Yandex 360 with calendar and cloud storage. Custom domains are available through Yandex 360 for Business.

    Based in Russia. Score 28/100.

  37. 37. AT&T Mail Grade F

    Free, ad-supported email service from AT&T for att.net and currently.com addresses and legacy sbcglobal.net, bellsouth.net and ameritech.net accounts. It runs on Yahoo Mail. A paid Yahoo Mail Plus plan removes ads.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 26/100.

  38. 38. Lavabit Grade F

    Email service from Lavabit LLC in the United States, founded by Ladar Levison. Its Magma mail server is open source. New registrations are closed, and the website states that mail services remain online.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 26/100.

  39. 39. Atomic Mail Grade F

    Email service from AtomicMail Systems OÜ in Estonia, with a free plan and paid Plus and Business plans. Mail between Atomic Mail users can be end-to-end encrypted, and password-protected mail can be sent to others.

    Based in Estonia. Score 25/100.

  40. 40. Mail.com Grade F

    Free, ad-supported email service from 1&1 Mail & Media, part of United Internet, offering addresses on many domains such as mail.com and email.com. A paid Premium plan adds IMAP, POP3 and phone support.

    Based in the United States (Five Eyes). Score 25/100.

How this list is made

Entries are ranked with our picks first, then by score against public criteria. Every answer links to evidence, and hosted services are tested automatically. The list updates when ratings change.

Compare all: email providers. Criteria and scoring.

Questions

Which email service is the best?

Our pick is listed first with the reason. For privacy, look for encrypted storage, open source, no ads and independent audits; for reliability, check the live tests of each service's mail servers.